Boards, chief executives, and management

Governing and managing are related roles

A nongovernmental organization (NGO) can divide responsibility among a governing board, a chief executive officer (CEO), managers, staff, members, and volunteers. Titles vary. For charities in England and Wales, the Charity Commission explains that trustees share ultimate responsibility for governance, even when their titles include director, governor, or management committee member. A title should therefore be read alongside the governing document. [1]

Delegation needs boundaries

Charity Commission decision-making guidance says that delegating decisions to staff or committees does not remove trustees’ accountability. It recommends defined authority and reporting arrangements. For example, a board might authorize a manager to purchase supplies within an approved budget while reserving a major borrowing decision. The example illustrates delegation; the actual limits must come from that organization’s rules. [2]

Paid work is not the same as paid participation

The United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) evaluates reasonable compensation by comparison with similar services under comparable circumstances. Salary can pay for accounting, counseling, administration, or leadership. A payroll entry identifies employment compensation; it does not establish that people attending a separate protest were paid to participate. That claim would require records connecting a payment with attendance or another specified service. [3]

Why the division can help or fail

Specialization can let a board scrutinize strategy while trained staff deliver services. Problems can arise if directors receive incomplete information, managers lack clear authority, or conflicts are ignored. In a hypothetical food-distribution program, the board might approve safeguards, the executive coordinate staff, and volunteers distribute supplies. If complaints go unanswered, investigate who received them, who had authority to respond, and whether reporting procedures operated.

Trace decisions rather than assuming control

Read the constitution, delegation policy, meeting records where available, and role descriptions. Ask who appoints the executive, approves the budget, evaluates performance, and hears complaints. An advisory council may supply expertise without voting power. A donor may recommend a project without employing its staff. Distinguishing formal powers from access and persuasion makes criticism more precise and helps identify where accountability should operate.

People, institutions and evidence

Related learning

Palestine Solidarity Campaign: governance, leadership and accounts

Médecins Sans Frontières: medical operations and distributed leadership

View the twenty-topic guide

External Resources